| Type | Class | Qty | Numbers | Year Built | Builder | Examples |
| 4-4-0 | B | 4 | 1-4 | 1895-1898 | Cooke & NYO&W |
1 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
2 at Walton, NY (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
3 at Summitville, NY, 1915 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
4 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 4-4-0 | C | 7 | 10-16 | 1896-1898 | Cooke & Dickson |
11 at Cornwall, NY (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
13 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
14 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 4-4-0 | F | 1 | 7 | 1871 | Baldwin | |
| 4-4-0 | inspection | | | | |
unknown (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
38 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 0-6-0 | L | 6 | 50-56 | 1910-1911 | Cooke & Rome |
50 Oswego, NY 1939 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
51 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
52 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
53 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
54 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
54 in Middleton, NY 1933 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
54 in Middleton, NY 1930 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
55 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
56 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 2-6-0 | J | 7 | 115-121 | 1898-1902 | Cooke & Rome |
116 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
121 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 2-6-0 | R | 11 | 126-136 | 1889-1890 | Dickson |
135 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
|
| 2-6-0 | T | 4 | 139-142 | 1893 | Dickson |
140 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 2-6-0 | T | 5 | 143-147 | | Cooke |
143 in Norwich, NY 1915 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
144 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 2-6-0 | U | 8 | 240-256 | 1901-1905 | Cooke |
248 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
250 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
251 near New Durham 1932 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
255 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
255 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
|
| 2-6-0 | V | 15 | 271-285 | 1908-1909 | Cooke |
271 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
271 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
272 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
273 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
275 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
281 near Middletown, NY 1937 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
285 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
|
| 4-6-0 | U-1 | 9 | 241-255 | 1901-1905 | Cooke & Dickson |
244 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
246 (Railfan.net Usenet ABPR Picture Archives)
246 in Weehauken, NJ (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
246 & 251 near Middletown (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 2-8-0 | S | 42 | 151-192 | 1890-1894 | Dickson |
151 in Norwich, NY 1915 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
153 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
155 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
159 with Erie vanderbuilt tender (Vandy tender inherited from an Erie Class H-4 2-8-0. Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
159 with Erie vanderbuilt tender (Sands Creek trestle near Delaware River Bridge 1911. Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
159 (On Delaware River Bridge with fill train. Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
161 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
165 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
168 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
172 at Constansta, NY (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
184 at Campbell Hall, 1900 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 2-8-0 | P | 20 | 201-220 | 1900-1904 | Cooke |
207 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
210 at Mayfield Yard 1937 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
213 at Olive St. Yard, Scranton 1938 (Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|
| 2-8-0 | E | 1 | 701 | 1893 | Dickson (ex D&H) |
701 at Mayfield Yard (Purchased in 1948. Photo courtesy Walter Kierzkowski)
|