Columbia & Red Mountain / Great Northern / Washington & Spokane Falls 2-8-0 "Consolidation" Type Locomotives

Class 39 / F-1 (Locobase 2616)

Data from 1899 Brooks Catalogue.

Builder info from B.Rumary, 25 Kingscombe, Gurney Slade, Radstock, BA3 4TH, ENGLAND and Jeremy Lambert as supplied by Allen Stanley in March 2004. Works #2269 manufactured in April 1893 and shown at the Chicago World's Fair.

Tandem compound Consolidation that had less heating area than the Brooks Mogul delivered a couple of years later. It had an Improved Belpaire boiler.

Manufactured beginning in June 1892, the batches included works #2093-2116 (road #450-473, renumbered 516-539 in 1899), 2133-2157 (474-499, 540-565) in August-September 1892, and 2187-2201 (500-514) in November-December 1892.

Class 40 / F-2 - compound (Locobase 8826)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection. works numbers were 12817-12820, 12823 in July 1892.

In the same year that Brooks was delivering several dozen Consolidations to the GN (Locobase 2616), Baldwin supplied 5 tandem compounds of their own. These were bigger and had much larger grates in their Belpaire fireboxes. The difference came from a wide firebox that rode above the drivers.

As with the Brooks engines, this quintet was soon simpled - see Locobase 8826.

Class 50 / F-5 (Locobase 8825)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

Delivered right at the turn of the century, these Consolidations were typical of the breed. Locobase isn't sure, but suspects that they arrived as compounds and were later simpled. Note the usual Belpaire firebox, this time as part of a design that featured a long stroke.

Like many of the GN's earlier 2-8-0s, most were never superheated. Those that were appear in Locobase 8826.

Class 50A / F-7 (Locobase 8830)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

1901 saw the Great Northern purchase several classes of Consolidations from several builders. They shared many things: all came from manufacturers that would soon be gathered under the American Locomotive Company banner, all had Belpaire boilers, all had 55" drivers. Rogers' F-5 engines are shown in Locobase 8825 and the superheated F-6s originally supplied by Brooks appear in Locobase 8830.

These Cookes had 10 fewer boiler tubes than did the Rogers F-5s, but otherwise were quite similar. They were later superheated, the result of which is shown in Locobase 8831.

Class 50B / F-6 (Locobase 8849)

Data from Data from GN 1916 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

These long-stroke, Belpaire-boilered Consolidations continued the line of such 2-8-0s that began with the Rogers F-5 engines.

Class 51B / F-9 (Locobase 8850)

Data from Data from GN 1916 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

This class combined the basic power dimensions of Brooks's F-6 Consolidations (Locobase 8849) with a bigger grate in its Belpaire firebox. Most were superheated not long after they entered service; see Locobase 8851.

Class F-1 - simpled (Locobase 8823)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

Locobase 2616 describes the original tandem-compound layout of this large class of Consolidations. Not long after it entered service, however, the railroad changed the class over to simple expansion. The dimensions are slightly different, but that's likely more because the railroad was measuring rather than Brooks. The essential details of a Belpaire firebox, small drivers, and large tubes remained the same. For a time, the boilers were pressed to 160 psi, but working pressure later rose to 185 psi as shown in the specs.

A very few were superheated; see Locobase 8824.

Class F-1-S (Locobase 8824)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

Taking the basic simple-expansion F-1 rebuild described in Locobase 8823, the GN later superheated a few. Two had the layout shown in the specs, in which the 22 flues measured 5 1/2" in diameter; another had 5" flues, which held smaller elements and resulted in a 8-sq ft drop in superheater area. Other than the usual tradoff of tubes for flues and a reduction in boiler pressure to 150 psi, a level more usually seen in the 1880s, the Belpaire-boilered F-1s were essentially the same.

The GN eventually reset the working pressure to 175 psi.

Class F-11 (Locobase 8832)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

The design is certainly foreign to the GN, having a round-topped boiler and small dimensions.

Class F-2 - simpled (Locobase 8827)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

Other than taking off the two LP cylinders and enlarging the HP cylinders to 19", the GN made very few changes on these 5 Consolidations. The signature Belpaire firebox mated to a wide grate and an overall stubby look remained a part of the profile.

Four of the 5 were scrapped in June 1928; 596 didn't join them at the ferro-knacker's until September 1929.

Class F-4 (Locobase 8848)

Data from Data from GN 1916 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

This single Consolidation was owned by the Spokane Falls & Northern, but operated on the C & RM. The C & RM was a gold-mine creation in 1895 that ascended the Paterson valley in Stevens County from Northport to Rossland to exploit the Red Mountain gold strikes in northeastern Washington State. Not long afterward, the Great Northern bought the CR & M and renumbered the 9 as their 1094.

Class F-5-S (Locobase 8828)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

Superheating the F-5s, first delivered in 1901 and shown in Locobase 8827, meant retaining the Belpaire firebox, but subtracting several dozen tubes to accommodate the odd-sized flues. It was apparently usual GN practice (but much less common elsewhere) to increase the cylinder diameter substantially at the same time; they were served by 12" piston valves.

At the time of the upgrade, the working boiler pressure was lowered to 175 psi, but it was later restored to 210 psi. When that occurred, the GN had a powerful little 2-8-0 indeed.

Class F-6-S (Locobase 8829)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

These Brooks machines were delivered in the same year as the F-5 came from Rogers (Locobase 8825) and the F-7s from Cooke (Locobase 8830). Like all Great Northern engines of the day, were fitted with a relatively narrow Belpaire firebox. They were superheated with one of two different designs; the GN's own installation yielded 444 sq ft compared the H & D equipment shown in the specs.

All of the class was converted to an 0-8-0 switcher layout.

Class F-7-S (Locobase 8831)

Data from Data from GN 1-1929 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

When the Great Northern superheated this set of Cooke-built Consolidations, they used the same layout as the F-5 superheating project described in Locobase 8828. At that point, the only difference was a lower adhesion weight in these F-7-S locomotives. Part of the upgrade consisted of dropping the working pressure to 165 psi. Unlike other 2-8-0 engines, however, these do not appear to have the original, higher working pressure restored later on.

Class F-8 (cross-compound) (Locobase 4129)

Part of the largest class of Consolidations on the Great Northern, these were the cross-compound variant. Data from 1901 Railroad Gazette (XXXIII, #24). Notice the good ratio of high to low pressure, although these engines, like most US rigid compounds, probably were converted to simple-expansion F-8s not long after their introduction.

Class F-8 (simple) (Locobase 2801)

This was by far the largest class of Consolidations on the Great Northern. Baldwin, Brooks, and Rogers all supplied engines of this class. This entry shows the narrow-firebox, simple-expansion variant. Other engines in this class included some with a wide firebox (59 sq ft) and others were 2-cylinder cross-compounds. (See separate entries.) Data from 1901 Railroad Gazette (XXXIII, #24).

Some were superheated in the 1920s. According to Larry Bohn (http://www.prostar.com/web/gngoat/gn27011.htm), the engine in his photograph #1230 was completed by Baldwin in November 1907 and scrapped in 1954.

Class F-8 (wide firebox) (Locobase 4128)

Members of the largest class of Consolidations on the Great Northern, this variant was described in a 1901 Railroad Gazette (Vol XXXIII, #24) as part of a Rogers delivery along with two other variants. See the other F-8 entries.

Class F-8 - superheater (Locobase 6451)

According to the diagram reproduced on Ben Ringnalda's http://www.greatnorthernempire.net/GNEGNSteamRosterO1_4.htm (visited 7 Jan 2005), this series of superheated F-8s included a variety of tube & flue layouts that resulted in slightly different surface areas. Most seem to have had the numbers shown in the specifications. Noteworthy to Locobase is the combination of retained Stephenson link motion and piston valves in a US engine that was refitted with superheaters. The piston valves measured a respectable 12" in diameter.

All had 30 5" flues, but the surface area varied on the type of superheater, ranging from 448 sq ft as shown to 475 sq ft to 505 sq ft. Some had arch tubes totalling 30 sq ft as part of the firebox heating surface, which increased the total to 225 sq ft.

The small tube counts shown in the 12 survivors on Ringnalda's duplicated diagram show as follows:

Tubes Area

189 2,012

203 2,158

205 2,173

217 2,226

236 2,371

237 2,379

Class F-9-S (Locobase 8851)

Data from Data from GN 1916 locomotive diagram book supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection.

When superheating was applied to this class's boilers, the railroad took the unusual step of greatly increasing the cylinder volume. The boiler's total heating surface remained approximately the same as did the grate in the Belpaire firebox.

It was too much of a good thing, most likely, given how little boiler there was for every cubic inch of cylinder. By the late 1920s, the GN had converted the whole class to C-3-S 0-8-0 switchers. Some had 21" cylinders, others 23 1/2".

Specifications
Class39 / F-140 / F-2 - compound50 / F-550A / F-750B / F-651B / F-9F-1 - simpledF-1-SF-11F-2 - simpledF-4F-5-SF-6-SF-7-SF-8 (cross-compound)F-8 (simple)F-8 (wide firebox)F-8 - superheaterF-9-S
Locobase ID2616882688258830884988508823882488328827884888288829883141292801412864518851
RailroadGreat Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Washington & Spokane Falls (GN)Great Northern (GN)Columbia & Red Mountain (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)Great Northern (GN)
Whyte2-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-02-8-0
Road Numbers500-565500-504 / 550-554 / 595-5991095-11091130-11391110-11291300-1324500-565508, 511, 544-54614-15 / 590-591500-504 / 595-59991100-11041110-11291130-1133, 1136, 11381140-12531307+
GaugeStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStdStd
BuilderBrooksBurnham, Williams & CoRogersCookeAlco-BrooksAlco-BrooksBrooksGNAlcoBurnham, Williams & CoBurnham, Williams & CoGNAlco-BrooksGNRogersseveralRogersshopsGN
Year1892189219011901190119031892191319121910189619131913191319011901190119211913
Valve GearStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonStephensonWalschaertWalschaertWalschaertWalschaertStephenson
Locomotive Length and Weight
Driver Wheelbase15.50'15.50'15.50'16'16'16'15.50'15.50'14.83'15.50'12.42'15.50'16'16'16'16'16'16'16'
Engine Wheelbase23'23.33'23.33'24.25'24.75'25.17'23'23'22.67'23.33'20.08'23.33'24.75'24.25'24.25'24.25'24.25'24.25'25.25'
Ratio of driving wheelbase to overall engine wheebase 0.67 0.66 0.66 0.66 0.65 0.64 0.67 0.67 0.65 0.66 0.62 0.66 0.65 0.66 0.66 0.66 0.66 0.66 0.63
Overall Wheelbase (engine & tender)50'50.71'50.71'55.92'53.92'57.50'50.17'50.17'49.58'50.71'45.08'50.71'55.92'55.92'58'58'58'60.06'57.50'
Axle Loading (Maximum Weight per Axle)32500 lbs44750 lbs43500 lbs44525 lbs45000 lbs30000 lbs30000 lbs30750 lbs32500 lbs28525 lbs44750 lbs44525 lbs43500 lbs48000 lbs45000 lbs
Weight on Drivers130000 lbs130000 lbs179000 lbs174000 lbs178100 lbs180000 lbs120000 lbs120000 lbs123000 lbs130000 lbs113300 lbs179000 lbs178100 lbs174000 lbs174000 lbs172000 lbs172000 lbs192000 lbs180000 lbs
Engine Weight147000 lbs145000 lbs194000 lbs194000 lbs195500 lbs196000 lbs136000 lbs136000 lbs138000 lbs145000 lbs135000 lbs194000 lbs195500 lbs194000 lbs195000 lbs192000 lbs192000 lbs207680 lbs196000 lbs
Tender Light Weight85000 lbs86000 lbs137000 lbs131000 lbs125400 lbs123000 lbs86000 lbs86000 lbs100000 lbs86000 lbs82000 lbs137000 lbs137000 lbs131000 lbs168000 lbs123000 lbs
Total Engine and Tender Weight232000 lbs231000 lbs331000 lbs325000 lbs320900 lbs319000 lbs222000 lbs222000 lbs238000 lbs231000 lbs217000 lbs331000 lbs332500 lbs325000 lbs000375680 lbs319000 lbs
Tender Water Capacity4000 gals4000 gals6000 gals6000 gals6000 gals6000 gals4000 gals4000 gals5000 gals4000 gals3400 gals6000 gals6000 gals6000 gals8000 gals6000 gals
Tender Fuel Capacity (oil/coal)8 tons8 tons4000 gals14 tons12 tons12 tons8 tons8 tons9 tons8 tons10 tons4000 gals14 tons14 tons tons tons tons4500 gals12 tons
Minimum weight per yard of rail on which locomotive could run54 lb rail54 lb rail75 lb rail73 lb rail74 lb rail75 lb rail50 lb rail50 lb rail51.25 lb rail54 lb rail47.21 lb rail74.58 lb rail74.21 lb rail72.50 lb rail72.50 lb rail71.67 lb rail71.67 lb rail80 lb rail75 lb rail
Geometry Relating to Tractive Effort
Driver Diameter55"55"55"55"55"55"55"55"52"55"47"55"55"55"55"55"55"55"55"
Boiler Pressure180 psi160 psi210 psi210 psi210 psi210 psi185 psi175 psi180 psi160 psi180 psi210 psi165 psi165 psi210 psi210 psi210 psi180 psi180 psi
Cylinders (dia x stroke)13" x 26"13" x 26"20" x 32"20" x 32"20" x 32"20" x 32"19" x 26"22" x 26"20" x 24"19" x 26"19" x 24"23.5" x 32"23.5" x 32"23.5" x 32"22" x 32" (1)20" x 32"20" x 32"23.5" x 32"26" x 32"
Low Pressure Cylinders (dia x stroke)22" x 26"22" x 26"" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "" x "33" x 32"" x "" x "" x "" x "
Tractive Effort18120 lbs16106 lbs41542 lbs41542 lbs41542 lbs41542 lbs26835 lbs34034 lbs28246 lbs23209 lbs28204 lbs57354 lbs45064 lbs45064 lbs34799 lbs41542 lbs41542 lbs49160 lbs60176 lbs
Factor of Adhesion (Weight on Drivers/Tractive Effort) 7.17 8.07 4.31 4.19 4.29 4.33 4.47 3.53 4.35 5.60 4.02 3.12 3.95 3.86 5.00 4.14 4.14 3.91 2.99
Heating Ability
Firebox Area177 sq. ft193 sq. ft206 sq. ft206 sq. ft198.60 sq. ft217.30 sq. ft176 sq. ft176 sq. ft148 sq. ft193 sq. ft171.25 sq. ft206 sq. ft198.60 sq. ft206 sq. ft212 sq. ft212 sq. ft200 sq. ft195 sq. ft217.30 sq. ft
Grate Area25.30 sq. ft53.90 sq. ft35.66 sq. ft35.66 sq. ft38.94 sq. ft57.50 sq. ft24.60 sq. ft24.60 sq. ft31.40 sq. ft53.90 sq. ft24 sq. ft35.66 sq. ft34.94 sq. ft35.66 sq. ft35.30 sq. ft35.30 sq. ft59 sq. ft59 sq. ft57.50 sq. ft
Evaporative Heating Surface1596203327952717282828161586129118072033184422612554226127122712270024212526
Superheating Surface270505475505448500
Combined Heating Surface1596203327952717282828161586156118072033184427663029276627122712270028693026
Evaporative Heating Surface/Cylinder Volume399.57508.98240.21233.51243.05242.02185.89112.86207.07238.28234.13140.75158.99140.75385.25233.08232.05150.71128.46
Computations Relating to Power Output (More Information)
Robert LeMassena's Power Computation4554862474897489817712075455143055652862443207488.605765.105883.9074137413123901062010350
Same as above plus superheater percentage455486247489748981771207545515049.625652862443208855.826669.176958.15741374131239012278.3312060.18
Same as above but substitute firebox area for grate area3186030880432604326041706456333256036127.3526640308803082551158.1637907.7540195.6944520445204200040580.9345576.99
Power L135793844632861996322645649016452.194553.0951544834.249389.957364.647377.824584.366240.466121.347629.466807.16
Power MT242.78260.76311.75314.17313.03316.29360.16474.15326.43349.62376.26462.60364.65373.91232.34319.95313.84350.42333.49

Reference

Credits

Introduction and specifications provided by Steve Llanso of Sweat House Media.