| No. | Class | F.M. Whyte | Gauge | Railroad Line | Location | Status | Builder Info | Notes |
|---|
| 18 | | 2-8-0 | 4'-8½" | Boyne City | Arcade & Attica Railroad, Arcade, NY | out of service | ALCO (Cooke) #62624, 1920 | Crack in boiler. |
| 14 | | 4-6-0 | 4'-8½" | E&LS | Arcade & Attica Railroad, Arcade, NY | display | Baldwin #45083, 1917 | |
| 14 | | 0-6-0ST | 4'-8½" | BEDT | Ulster & Delaware RR Historical Society, Arkville, NY | cosmetic restoration | H.K. Porter #6260, 08/1920 | |
| 2 | | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | Marion River Carry Railroad | Adirondack Museum, Blue Mountain Lake, NY | display | H.K. Porter #2396, 08/1901 | |
| 3 | 18 ton | 0-4-0ST | 36" | General Crushed Stone Co. | Central Square Staition Museum, Central Square, NY | display | Vulcan Iron Works (Wilkes-Barre), 09/1922 | |
| 53 | 40 ton | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | Solvay Process Works | Central Square Staition Museum, Central Square, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke) #63278, 1923 | From Rail City, Sandy Pond, NY |
| 8 (15) | 50-2 | Shay2Tr | 4'-8½" | Crosby Lumber & Mfg | RHSNNY, Croghan, NY | out of service | Lima #2977, 1918 | From Eureka Springs, AR |
| 22 (10) | | 0-4-0F | 4'-8½" | Dunlop | Curriers Depot, Curriers, NY | display | H.K. Porter #7187, 08/1930 | From Erie Country Fiargrounds, Hamburg |
| 5361 | P2e | 2-8-2 | 4'-8½" | CPR | Gould Coupler (industrial park), Depew, NY | display | CLC #1775, 09/1926 | Sold |
| 444 | G-11b | 0-6-0 | 4'-8½" | B&M | Alco-Brooks Railroad Display, Dunkirk, NY | display | ALCO (Brooks) #56532, 1916 | |
| 6 | | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | American Viscose | Scott Symans, Dunkirk, NY | private operational | Baldwin #57994, 09/1924 | From Gem City Iron & Metal, Pulaski, VA |
| 1 | | 0-4-0T | 4'-8½" | Humphrey's Pure Oil | Scott Symans, Dunkirk, NY | restoration | Baldwin #54075, 1920 | From Waco then San Angelo, TX |
| | 4-4-0 | 24" | | Rotunda Grapevine Railroad Farm, Fredonia, NY | unknown | Crown Metal Products (Elizabeth) | Sold. Going to Salt Lake City |
| 4483 | I1sa | 2-10-0 | 4'-8½" | PRR | Western NY Railway Hist Soc, Hamburg, NY | display | Baldwin #56534, 1923 | Restoration candidate with the proper funding. May be moved to the Heritage Discovery Center. |
| 63 | | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | SPC | Station Restaurant, Ithaca, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke) #66314, 1928 | |
| 55 | 40 ton | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | Allied Chemical | Hanson Aggregates, Jamesville, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke), 08/1928 | |
| | 4-4-0 | 15" | | Herschell Carrousel Factory Museum, North Tonawanda, NY | display | Armitage-Herschell #0001, 1896 | |
| 35 | G-5s | 4-6-0 | 4'-8½" | LIRR | Oyster Bay Railroad Museum, Oyster Bay, NY | restoration | PRR #4201, 1928 | From Eisenhower Park, awaiting movement to Alabama for restoration |
| 23 | | 2-8-0 | 4'-8½" | LS&I | Empire State Railway Museum, Phoenicia, NY | restoration | ALCO (Pittsburg) #46939, 1910 | |
| 1 | | 0-4-0T | 40" | Defiance Coal | Railroad Museum of Long Island, Riverhead, NY | restoration | H.K. Porter #6687, 10/1921 | From Rail City, then John Degan, Southampton |
| 16 | 14 | 0-6-0T | 4'-8½" | BEDT (ALH&P) | Railroad Museum of Long Island, Riverhead, NY | display | H.K. Porter #6780, 1/1923 | |
| 16 | 8 ton | 0-4-0T | 24" | Indian Valley | Erie Canal Village, Rome, NY | stored operational | Davenport Locomotive Works #961, 1910 | from Long Island, NY and Frontier Town, Lake George, NY, to Erie Canal Village, Rome, NY |
| 47 | 40 ton | 0-4-0T | 4'-8½" | Solvay Process Works | New York Museum of Transportation, Rush, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke), 1920 | |
| 2 | | 0-4-0F | 4'-8½" | Connecticut Power | Rochester & Genesee Valley Railroad Museum, Rush, NY | display | Heisler #60, 05/1941 | |
| 12 | | 0-4-0T | 4'-8½" | US Navy | Rochester & Genesee Valley Railroad Museum, Rush, NY | restoration | Vulcan Iron Works (Wilkes-Barre) #2854, 1918 | Formerly in tourist train service in a residential New York neighborhood. |
| | 4-4-0 | 15" | Harris Steam Farm | Harris Steam Farm, Sanborn, NY | operational | Crown Metal Products (Elizabeth) | |
| | 4-4-0 | 15" | Harris Steam Farm | Harris Steam Farm, Sanborn, NY | operational | Crown Metal Products (Elizabeth), 1962 | |
| | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | American Viscose | Joseph Rodney Estate, Silver Creek, NY | restoration | H.K. Porter #7209, 1934 | from Gem City Iron & Metal, Pulaski, VA. For sale |
| 60 | 30 ton | 0-4-0T | 42" | Lehigh Coal & Navigation | Central Hudson Railways, Staatsburg, NY | restoration? | H.K. Porter #7795, 04/1945 | from Phoenixville, PA then Middletown, bought by Donald Seifert in 2006 |
| 1 | D | 4-4-0 | 15" | Hiawatha Live Steamers | Hiawatha Live Steamers, Tupper Lake, NY | operational | Wasatch Railroad Contractors, 06/2013 | |
| 5433 | J-3 | 4-6-4 | 15" | NYC | Hiawatha Live Steamers, Tupper Lake, NY | operational | Seymour Johnson, 1968 | From Bell Gardens, Valley Center, CA |
| 6721 | B-11k | 0-6-0 | 4'-8½" | NYC | Union Station, Utica, NY | display | ALCO (Schenectady) #54075, 12/1913 | from Carillon Park, Dayton, OH |
| | 0-4-0T | 600mm | | steel fabricating firm on Rt 9, Valatie, NY | display | Maffei (Munich) #4125, 1925 | from Arthur Seifert, Hopewell Junction |
| | 0-4-0F | 4'-8½" | The Stanley Works | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | H.K. Porter | damaged in fire from CT Trolley Museum |
| 5 | | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | HELC | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | ALCO, 1920 | from CT Trolley Museum |
| 100 | D-9 | 0-4-0T | 24" | C&NW | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | Davenport Locomotive Works #1543, 1915 | from Black Hills Central, later Edaville, later Pascog, RI |
| 44 | | 2-4-0 | | Carnegie-Illinois Steel | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | H.K. Porter #2634, 09/1902 | from Frontier Town, Lake George, NY |
| 1 | | 2-6-2 | 24" | Rome & Fort Bull Railroad | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | Nolan | from Erie Canal Village, Rome, NY |
