| No. | Class | F.M. Whyte | Gauge | Railroad Line | Location | Status | Builder Information | Notes |
|---|
| 18 | | 2-8-0 | 4'-8½" | Boyne City |  Arcade & Attica Railroad, Arcade, NY | operational | ALCO (Cooke) #62624, 1920 |   |
| 14 | | 4-6-0 | 4'-8½" | E&LS | Arcade & Attica Railroad, Arcade, NY | display | Baldwin #45083, 1917 | |
| 14 | | 0-6-0ST | 4'-8½" | BEDT | Ulster & Delaware RR Historical Society, Arkville, NY | cosmetic restoration | H.K. Porter #6260, 08/1920 | |
| 2 | | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | Marion River Carry Railroad | Adirondack Museum, Blue Mountain Lake, NY | display | H.K. Porter #2396, 08/1901 |  |
| 53 | 40 ton | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | Solvay Process Works | Central Square Staition Museum, Central Square, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke) #63278, 1923 | From Rail City, Sandy Pond, NY |
| 3 | 18 ton | 0-4-0ST | 36" | General Crushed Stone Co. | Central Square Staition Museum, Central Square, NY | display | Vulcan Iron Works (Wilkes-Barre), 09/1922 | |
| 8 (15) | 50-2 | Shay2Tr | 4'-8½" | Crosby Lumber & Mfg | RHSNNY, Croghan, NY | out of service | Lima #2977, 1918 | From Eureka Springs, AR |
| 22 (10) | | 0-4-0F | 4'-8½" | Dunlop | Curriers Depot, Curriers, NY | display | H.K. Porter #7187, 08/1930 | From Erie Country Fiargrounds, Hamburg |
| 5361 | P2e | 2-8-2 | 4'-8½" | CPR | Gould Coupler (industrial park), Depew, NY | display | CLC #1775, 09/1926 | |
| 444 | | 0-6-0 | 4'-8½" | B&M | Alco-Brooks Railroad Display, Dunkirk, NY | display | ALCO (Brooks) #56532, 1916 | |
| 6 | | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | American Viscose | Scott Symans, Dunkirk, NY | private operational | Baldwin #57994, 09/1924 | From Gem City Iron & Metal, Pulaski, VA |
| 1 | | 0-4-0T | 4'-8½" | Humphrey's Pure Oil | Scott Symans, Dunkirk, NY | restoration | Baldwin #54075, 1920 | From Waco then San Angelo, TX |
| | 4-4-0 | 24" | | Rotunda Grapevine Railroad Farm, Fredonia, NY | unknown | Crown Metal Products (Elizabeth) | |
| 4483 | I1sa | 2-10-0 | 4'-8½" | PRR | Western NY Railway Hist Soc, Hamburg, NY | display | Baldwin #56534, 1923 | Restoration candidate with the proper funding. May be moved to the Heritage Discovery Center. |
| 63 | | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | SPC | Station Restaurant, Ithaca, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke) #66314, 1928 | |
| 55 | 40 ton | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | Allied Chemical | Hanson Aggregates, Jamesville, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke), 08/1928 | |
| 23 | | 2-8-0 | 4'-8½" | LS&I | Empire State Railway Museum, Kingston, NY | restoration | ALCO (Pittsburgh) #46939, 1910 | |
| | 4-4-0 | 15" | | Herschell Carrousel Factory Museum, North Tonawanda, NY | operational | Armitage-Herschell #0001, 1896 | |
| 35 | G-5s | 4-6-0 | 4'-8½" | LIRR | Oyster Bay Station, Oyster Bay, NY | stored | PRR #4201, 1925 | From Eisenhower Park, awaiting movement to Alabama for restoration |
| 1 | | 0-4-0T | 40" | Defiance Coal | Railroad Museum of Long Island, Riverhead, NY | restoration | H.K. Porter #6687, 10/1921 |  From Rail City, then John Degan, Southampton |
| 16 | 14 | 0-6-0T | 4'-8½" | BEDT (ALH&P) | Railroad Museum of Long Island, Riverhead, NY | display | H.K. Porter #6780, 1/1923 | |
| 39 | G-5s | 4-6-0 | 4'-8½" | LIRR | Railroad Museum of Long Island, Riverhead, NY | restoration | PRR (Juniata) #4207, 6/1929 | From LIRR, then Stony Brook. Being moved to Strasburg, PA for restoration and operation. |
| 16 | 8 ton | 0-4-0T | 24" | Indian Valley | Erie Canal Village, Rome, NY | operational | Davenport #961, 1910 | from Long Island, NY and Frontier Town, Lake George, NY, to Erie Canal Village, Rome, NY |
| 47 | 40 ton | 0-4-0T | 4'-8½" | Solvay Process Works | New York Museum of Transportation, Rush, NY | display | ALCO (Cooke), 1920 | |
| 2 | | 0-4-0F | 4'-8½" | Connecticut Power | Rochester & Genesee Valley Railroad Museum, Rush, NY | display | Heisler #60, 05/1941 | |
| 12 | | 0-4-0T | 4'-8½" | US Navy | Rochester & Genesee Valley Railroad Museum, Rush, NY | restoration | Vulcan Iron Works (Wilkes-Barre) #2854, 1918 | |
| | 0-4-0ST | 4'-8½" | American Viscose | Rodney Estate, Silver Creek, NY | stored | H.K. Porter #7209, 1934 |  from Gem City Iron & Metal, Pulaski, VA. For sale |
| 60 | | 0-4-0T | 42" | Lehigh Navigation Coal Co. | Central Hudson Railways, Staatsburg, NY | restoration? | H.K. Porter #7795, 1945 | history uncertain, from Phoenixville, PA then Middletown, bought by Donald Seifert in 2006 |
| 6721 | B-11k | 0-6-0 | 4'-8½" | NYC | Union Station, Utica, NY | display | ALCO (Schenectady) #54075, 12/1913 | from Carillon Park, Dayton, OH |
| | 0-4-0T | 600mm | | steel fabricating firm on Rt 9, Valatie, NY | display | Maffei (Munich) #4125, 1925 | from Arthur Seifert, Hopewell Junction |
| | 0-4-0F | 4'-8½" | The Stanley Works | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | H.K. Porter | damaged in fire from CT Trolley Museum |
| 5 | | 0-4-0T | 4'-8½" | HELC | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | ALCO | from CT Trolley Museum |
| 100 | D-9 | 0-4-0T | 24" | C&NW | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | Davenport #1543, 1915 | from Black Hills Central, later Edaville, later Pascog, RI |
| 44 | | 2-4-0 | | | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | | from Frontier Town, Lake George, NY |
| 1 | | 2-6-2 | 24" | Rome & Fort Bull Railroad | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | Nolan | from Erie Canal Village, Rome, NY |
| 2968 | | 2-6-2 | 24" | Byron RR | Railstar, Black Clawson, Watertown, NY | stored | Davenport | from Monroe, WA |
from Long Island, NY and Frontier Town, Lake George, NY, to Erie Canal Village, Rome, NY 
history uncertain, from Phoenixville, PA then Middletown, bought by Donald Seifert in 2006 
damaged in fire from CT Trolley Museum 
from Black Hills Central, later Edaville, later Pascog, RI 
from Monroe, WA 
) icon.