See Locobase 4811 for a description of this Colorado sugar-beet railway.
Like all Pennsys, this design had a Belpaire firebox. (See Locobase 32 for a comment on the unique design of Pennsy's Belpaire firebox.)
The Railway Mechanical Engineer (RME) of January 1924 (pp 16-18) explains that local Pennsy traffic sometimes had to scale relatively steep grades. As traffic had grown over the previous decade, the railroad more frequently had to resort to double-heading its Atlantics.
As was usually the case with initial reports, RME reported the G5s was meeting exacting schedules and could run at 70 mph because the counterbalancing allowed for such speeds on a relatively low-drivered machine.
Once in service for a while, however, the class was considered to be rough riding, hard on water, hard to fire, and not suited for heavy snow because of the low placement of the air pump. It may at first seem hard to square this set of criticisms with Edson's verdict (Keystone Steam & Electric, 1974) that they were "...very successful not only on the Pittsburgh Division, but also in New Jersey and on the Long Island Railroad, which bought 31 of their own." But given the high factor of adhesion that Edson observes "...was needed for good acceleration from numerous stops in such service,", the ill effects on the crew were apparently more than offset by the engine's ability to keep a schedule.
As delivered, these Ten-wheelers had a representive set of component suppliers, as shown in the table:
Air brakes Westinghouse American
Axles Steel to Penn RR requirements
Bell ringer "Little Giant"
Boiler lagging Keasbey & Mattlson
Brake-beams National-Hollow
Brake-shoes Company standard
Couplers Kelso
Headlights Star
Injectors Nathan and Simplex
Journal bearings Phosphor bronze
Piston rod packings United States
Valve rod packing American Locomotive Co.
Safety valve Kunkle
Sanding devices Leach
Sight-feed lubricators Nathan
Springs Union Spring Co.
Steam gauges Crosby
Steam heat equipment Company's standard
Tires, tender wheels Schoen steel
Tlres, driving and truck wheels Standard
All were superheated later and taken into the Pennsy.
This set of Ten-wheelers was designed by the GR & I's Master Mechanic James Keegan as dual-service engines. In the summer resort season, they pulled heavy passenger trains; at other times they hauled freight. In the latter capacity, they were described in freight service as "...doing exceptionally well."
The railroad began as a lumber-exploiting line in Michigan that connected Grand Rapids with Cedar Springs (20 miles to the north) but eventually extended from Mackinaw City on the Straits of Mackinac to New Paris, Ohio, which was just a short distance from Cincinnati on the Pennsylvania.
According to Wikipedia, depletion of the northern Michigan forests in the 1880s prompted a successful transition to a tourism-based economy and the GR & I's nickname of "The Fishing Line" (Locobase wonders how long they cast about for ideas before that one hit.)
Profiled in the American Engineer and Railroad Journal of April 1896, this cross-compound design used the "Pittsburgh" system. "One feature of this system," said the anonymous author of the article,"is the independent exhaust from the high-pressure cylinder." Working simple at low speeds, the author goes on to explain, offers substantial benefits on those divisions of the line that have heavy grades "...as it permits the engine to take a heavier load over the limiting grade of the division, a load which can usually be easily handled on the remainder of the division."
Stacked against the other American TenWheelers of the decade, this design is about in the middle of the pack.
| Specifications | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Class | D/G1 | E/G2 | G | G4A | G5s | GG | GG-4 / G34 | VG6a / G26a | X | X/G3 |
| Locobase ID | 1135 | 1136 | 11501 | 3176 | 118 | 11439 | 9513 | 5845 | 1153 | 3175 |
| Railroad | Pennsylvania (PRR) | Pennsylvania (PRR) | New York, Philadelphia & Norfolk (PRR) | Pennsylvania (PRR) | Pennsylvania (PRR) | Grand Rapids & Indiana (PRR) | Grand Rapids & Indiana (PRR) | Vandalia Line (PRR) | Pennsylvania (PRR) | Pennsylvania (PRR) |
| Whyte | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 | 4-6-0 |
| Road Numbers | 25-27 | 1961 | 67-69, 28-29, 71, 9 | 258-59 / 508-09 / 8987-88 | ||||||
| Gauge | Std | Std | Std | Std | Std | Std | Std | Std | Std | Std |
| Builder | Burnham, Williams & Co | Altoona | Juniata | Alco | Burnham, Williams & Co | Pittsburgh | Ft Wayne | |||
| Year | 1868 | 1869 | 1904 | 1899 | 1924 | 1907 | 1899 | 1895 | 1893 | 1892 |
| Valve Gear | Stephenson | Stephenson | Stephenson | Stephenson | Walschaert | Stephenson | Stephenson | Stephenson | Stephenson | Stephenson |
| Locomotive Length and Weight | ||||||||||
| Driver Wheelbase | 12.42' | 12.67' | 13.50' | 13.10' | 14.25' | 13.50' | 11' | 11.83' | 11.83' | |
| Engine Wheelbase | 23.67' | 23.67' | 24.33' | 25.42' | 26.50' | 21.67' | 23.04' | 23.04' | ||
| Ratio of driving wheelbase to overall engine wheebase | 0.52 | 0.54 | 0.55 | 0.52 | 0.54 | 0.51 | 0.51 | 0.51 | ||
| Overall Wheelbase (engine & tender) | 45.83' | 45.83' | 56.10' | 64.94' | 49.79' | 51.15' | 51.12' | |||
| Axle Loading (Maximum Weight per Axle) | 20800 lbs | 23000 lbs | 48000 lbs | 39050 lbs | 39050 lbs | |||||
| Weight on Drivers | 59200 lbs | 62100 lbs | 116420 lbs | 138000 lbs | 178000 lbs | 126000 lbs | 101530 lbs | 101000 lbs | 112550 lbs | 112550 lbs |
| Engine Weight | 84300 lbs | 84800 lbs | 148800 lbs | 182000 lbs | 237000 lbs | 165000 lbs | 134330 lbs | 127000 lbs | 138000 lbs | 138000 lbs |
| Tender Light Weight | 51400 lbs | 51400 lbs | 120000 lbs | 51400 lbs | 176000 lbs | 90000 lbs | 78700 lbs | 73000 lbs | 51400 lbs | |
| Total Engine and Tender Weight | 135700 lbs | 136200 lbs | 268800 lbs | 233400 lbs | 413000 lbs | 261000 lbs | 224330 lbs | 205700 lbs | 211000 lbs | 189400 lbs |
| Tender Water Capacity | 2400 gals | 2400 gals | 6650 gals | 8000 gals | 7800 gals | 6000 gals | 4500 gals | 4000 gals | 3900 gals | 3900 gals |
| Tender Fuel Capacity (oil/coal) | 4 tons | 4 tons | tons | 11 tons | 13 tons | 12 tons | tons | tons | 7.5 tons | 7.5 tons |
| Minimum weight per yard of rail on which locomotive could run | 32.89 lb rail | 34.50 lb rail | 65 lb rail | 76.67 lb rail | 98.89 lb rail | 70 lb rail | 56 lb rail | 56.11 lb rail | 62.53 lb rail | 62.53 lb rail |
| Geometry Relating to Tractive Effort | ||||||||||
| Driver Diameter | 56" | 50" | 68" | 68" | 68" | 68" | 60" | 56" | 68" | 68" |
| Boiler Pressure | 125 psi | 125 psi | 180 psi | 225 psi | 205 psi | 200 psi | 200 psi | 180 psi | 180 psi | 180 psi |
| Cylinders (dia x stroke) | 18" x 22" | 18" x 22" | 20" x 26" | 20" x 28" | 24" x 28" | 20" x 26" | 19" x 26" | 19" x 26" (1) | 19" x 24" | 19" x 24" |
| Tractive Effort | 13524 lbs | 15147 lbs | 23400 lbs | 31500 lbs | 41328 lbs | 26000 lbs | 26594 lbs | 17942 lbs | 19494 lbs | 19494 lbs |
| Factor of Adhesion (Weight on Drivers/Tractive Effort) | 4.38 | 4.10 | 4.98 | 4.38 | 4.31 | 4.85 | 3.82 | 5.63 | 5.77 | 5.77 |
| Heating Ability | ||||||||||
| Firebox Area | 95.97 sq. ft | 111.27 sq. ft | 142.70 sq. ft | 162 sq. ft | 177 sq. ft | 148 sq. ft | 152 sq. ft | 146.40 sq. ft | ||
| Grate Area | 14.50 sq. ft | 16.35 sq. ft | 43.70 sq. ft | 31 sq. ft | 55.19 sq. ft | 46 sq. ft | 28 sq. ft | 24 sq. ft | 31.32 sq. ft | 30.78 sq. ft |
| Evaporative Heating Surface | 1093 | 1096 | 2395 | 2814 | 2855 | 2800 | 2325 | 1805 | 1901 | 1902 |
| Superheating Surface | 613 | |||||||||
| Combined Heating Surface | 1093 | 1096 | 2395 | 2814 | 3468 | 2800 | 2325 | 1805 | 1901 | 1902 |
| Evaporative Heating Surface/Cylinder Volume | 168.68 | 169.15 | 253.34 | 276.39 | 194.74 | 296.18 | 272.50 | 423.11 | 241.37 | 241.50 |
| Computations Relating to Power Output (More Information) | ||||||||||
| Robert LeMassena's Power Computation | 1812.50 | 2043.75 | 7866 | 6975 | 11313.95 | 9200 | 5600 | 4320 | 5637.60 | 5540.40 |
| Same as above plus superheater percentage | 1812.50 | 2043.75 | 7866 | 6975 | 13313.79 | 9200 | 5600 | 4320 | 5637.60 | 5540.40 |
| Same as above but substitute firebox area for grate area | 11996.25 | 13908.75 | 25686 | 36450 | 42698.70 | 0 | 29600 | 27360 | 0 | 26352 |
| Power L1 | 2831.98 | 2656.36 | 6708 | 9076.83 | 14669.83 | 0 | 7185 | 4335.92 | 0 | 6822.62 |
| Power MT | 316.39 | 282.91 | 381.08 | 435.02 | 545.08 | 0 | 468.04 | 283.93 | 0 | 400.92 |
None of the Pennsy 4-6-0 Standard Designs were built between the years 1901 and 1923. However, there were a few odds and ends scattered about. Two examples were operated by the Long Island Rail Road and Grand Rapids & Indiana.
In the year 1924, the Pennsy locomotive inventory listed 164 Ten-Wheelers for passenger service and four for freight service. This was a period of change for the 4-6-0 as the new G5s class was being built by Juniata. The 4-6-0 might have well been developed into larger, high speed machines for use along level sections, but the railroad preferred to build 4-4-2s instead. All were built with superheaters and power reverse gear, but never got stokers or feedwater heaters.
| This page last modified: . | [Contact] | All material © 1999-2008 SteamLocomotive.com |